---
title: "Asking Claude to attack my idea mid-call — Mumr"
description: "The founder of Mumr asks Claude, mid-call, for five short questions against an idea the room just agreed on. He asks two out loud. Nothing joins the call."
canonical: "https://mumr.app/blog/ask-claude-to-attack-the-idea"
language: "en-GB"
last-updated: "2026-11-08T00:32:54+00:00"
source: "https://mumr.app — Markdown rendition of the HTML page at `canonical`"
---

From the founder

# I ask Claude to attack my idea while the call is still on

Somebody on a call proposes something, and the room likes it. That is the moment I trust least. Everyone is nodding, nobody has had time to think, and the next thing on the agenda is already waiting.

Last updated: 30 October 2026

For the last couple of months I do a small thing at that moment. Mumr is recording the call, and since version 1.10 it keeps [a small panel on the side of the screen](https://mumr.app/live-meeting-assistant) while it records. I type one line into it: “Challenge this idea. Five questions, short.” Claude reads the transcript up to that second, through my own Claude Code on my Mac, and comes back with a list.

Most of the list I ignore. The questions are not deep, and they do not need to be. The point is that they are not mine. I have been in the conversation for forty minutes, I like the people, and I want the idea to work. The list does not. Two of the five are usually things nobody in the room has asked, and I ask them out loud.

## Why it works better than thinking harder

I tried doing this in my head for years. It does not work in the moment, because the part of me that could find the hole is busy listening and being polite. A list from outside the conversation has none of that. It read the same forty minutes I heard and it has no stake in the answer.

It also works because the transcript is right there. The questions refer to what people said, with the names and the numbers they used, so I can say “you said the launch is in three weeks, what happens to the migration” instead of a vague “have we thought about risks”.

## What it is not

It is not a bot in the call. Nobody joins, nothing is announced, no participant sees anything. Mumr records the call on my Mac, the transcript stays on my Mac, and the question goes to Claude only when I press enter. Mumr itself sends nothing anywhere; the panel talks to the Claude Code CLI I already use for work, with my own account.

It is also not a summary machine. I do not ask it to recap the meeting while the meeting is happening. The one thing I ask for mid-call is pressure on the idea that everyone just agreed with.

## If you want to try it

Record the call with Mumr, expand the panel, and ask for questions instead of answers. Pick two. Ask them before the agenda moves on. The rest of the list you can read after the call, which is also where it belongs.

_Mumr is free on the Mac App Store. The live panel chats through your own Claude Code. Mumr for iPhone is free on the App Store too._

## Record your next meeting free

Mumr records the meeting’s audio and your mic, transcribes on your Mac, and writes the summary. No bot, no account, no minute cap.

[Get Mumr free](https://mumr.app/download)

Free on the Mac App Store · macOS 15 or later
